The College Football Playoff selection committee faces a potential dilemma: could three teams from the Big 12 Conference earn berths in the expanded playoff? As the 2026 season progresses, the conference's strong performance has raised the possibility.

Utah quarterback Byrd Ficklin celebrated a touchdown against Arizona on November 14, 2026, in Tucson, highlighting the Utes' offensive firepower. The Big 12's depth has prompted analysts to examine whether the league deserves multiple spots in the 12-team playoff format.

Deseret News reporter Brandon Judd explored the scenario on November 17, 2026, noting that the conference's top contenders have built compelling resumes. The debate centers on whether the selection committee will reward conference strength or prioritize diversity of representation.