The New York Giants sit atop the NFC East with a 5-2-1 record heading into Week 10 of the 2026 NFL season, but their strong start has sparked several overreactions among analysts and fans.
1. Fraudulent Division Leader?
Critics argue the Giants are a fraudulent first-place team because they have yet to defeat an opponent with a winning record. Their five wins have come against teams with a combined 13-30 record, and five of their remaining nine opponents have winning records. However, New York has no control over the schedule and has already upset the Dallas Cowboys and Houston Texans. The team is 4-1-1 in one-score games, a sign of resilience. A matchup against the Jacksonville Jaguars in Week 11 offers a chance to silence doubters.
2. Mistake Not Trading for a Running Back
The Giants pursued Indianapolis Colts running back Jonathan Taylor, offering a second- and fifth-round pick, but the Colts declined. ESPN’s Jordan Raanan reported the team also inquired about Atlanta Falcons back Bijan Robinson. General manager Joe Schoen opted not to increase the offer or acquire another back, despite the ground game being held under 90 yards in four games. The front office had limited draft capital after surrendering a fifth-round pick for quarterback J.J. McCarthy and a fourth-round pick to draft Malachi Fields. Acquiring Taylor, who turns 28 in January, would likely have cost a first-round pick and more, mortgaging the future for a short-term gain.
3. Premature Quarterback Competition Talk
After McCarthy completed 31 of 49 passes for 495 yards with one touchdown and one interception in his first five quarters as a starter, some suggested he could challenge Jaxson Dart for the starting job in 2027. Even a subpar performance against the Philadelphia Eagles in Week 9 did not quell that speculation. However, it is far too early to project a quarterback competition; McCarthy must first lead the team into the postseason and win a playoff game before any serious discussion about the 2027 starter begins.



