Columnist Walker Clement revisits a controversial moment from the Carolina Panthers' 16-13 victory over the New Orleans Saints on October 7, 2007. In the game at the Superdome, Panthers quarterback David Carr was flagged for intentional grounding, prompting a heated but successful argument with referee Gene Steratore and head linesman Paul Weidner. The call and its reversal became a talking point in the aftermath of the Panthers' win.
The photograph by Doug Benc captures Carr pleading his case as the officials confer. The incident highlights the fine line between a quarterback's intentional grounding and a legitimate throwaway under pressure.



