St. Louis Cardinals prospect Wetherholt fell short of winning the Rookie of the Year award after being left off two ballots in the voting process, according to a report by John Denton for Roundtable Sports on November 10, 2026.

The omission from a pair of ballots proved decisive in the final tally, though specific vote totals and the identity of the award winner were not disclosed in the initial report. Wetherholt, whose first name was not provided in the source material, had been considered a contender for the honor following his debut season with the Cardinals organization.

The voting results highlight the narrow margins that often separate candidates in major league baseball's rookie recognition. Further details regarding the complete ballot breakdown and the player who ultimately claimed the award are expected to be released by the Baseball Writers' Association of America.