The 2026 NFL trade deadline produced several blockbuster deals that shifted the Super Bowl landscape, but the moves that did not happen may be just as significant. The Indianapolis Colts turned down offers for star running back Jonathan Taylor because they did not receive the first-round pick they sought. Taylor, a three-time Pro Bowler with no guaranteed money on his contract in 2027 or 2028, remains a prime trade candidate for the offseason.

Other notable players who stayed with their teams include Dallas Cowboys wide receiver George Pickens, who could have fetched a sizable return but remains unsigned long-term; New York Jets edge rusher Will McDonald IV, who requested a trade due to limited playing time; and Los Angeles Chargers edge rusher Khalil Mack, who was not moved despite the team's 0-8 record. The Chargers also held onto quarterback Justin Herbert and receiver Ladd McConkey.

Tennessee Titans running back Tony Pollard drew interest after back-to-back 100-yard, five-touchdown performances, but the team drove a hard bargain. Jacksonville Jaguars receiver Brian Thomas Jr. has lost target share to teammates, while Arizona Cardinals safety Budda Baker, 31 next season, could be traded as the team rebuilds around a rookie quarterback. Philadelphia Eagles cornerback Riq Woolen, on an expiring deal, may leave in free agency, netting a compensatory pick. Cardinals edge rusher Josh Sweat, who requested a trade last spring, remains a candidate to move. Finally, Titans receiver Calvin Ridley has been phased out of the offense, and his dead cap hit drops from $22.5 million to $7.5 million this spring, making a trade more feasible.

All ten players are now names to monitor when the next trade window opens in March at the start of the 2027 league year.