Two-time AL Cy Young winner Tarik Skubal is the top free agent this offseason and expected to sign a record contract before the collective bargaining agreement expires on Dec. 1. The 30-year-old left-hander, represented by Scott Boras, could command a deal exceeding $400 million, surpassing the current pitching records held by Yoshinobu Yamamoto ($325 million total) and Max Scherzer ($43.3 million AAV). Several big-market teams, including the Blue Jays, Dodgers, and Mets, are pursuing Skubal.

Short-term, high-AAV option

Reports suggest the Dodgers prefer a shorter contract with a high annual salary, similar to deals signed by Framber Valdez, Bo Bichette, or Kyle Tucker. Such a deal would typically span three to four years with opt-outs, allowing Skubal to re-enter free agency as early as next offseason. However, ESPN reports Skubal currently has no interest in that structure.

Pros of a short-term deal

1. Maximize earnings: A short-term contract could let Skubal hit free agency again after a strong 2027 season, potentially driving his value even higher, especially if a future salary floor compels small-market contenders to spend.

2. Chance to set more records: Skubal already set an arbitration salary record ($32 million for 2026) and could break his own pitcher contract record in a future free agency cycle.

3. Freedom to change teams: An escape hatch if the fit proves poor — whether due to team performance, coaching clashes, or personal reasons.

Cons of a short-term deal

1. Injury and performance risk: Skubal has undergone three elbow surgeries, including Tommy John in 2017 and a minor procedure in May 2024. A setback could cost him a larger long-term guarantee.

2. Potential salary cap: The next CBA may introduce a salary cap with contract limits (e.g., five years at 15% of the cap for players changing teams), which could suppress his future market. Even a stricter competitive balance tax could reduce earning potential.

This offseason may represent Skubal's last chance to sign in a truly unrestricted market.