Gotham FC has relocated its NWSL playoff semifinal against the Kansas City Current from Sports Illustrated Stadium in Harrison, New Jersey, to Icahn Stadium on Manhattan's Randall's Island due to concerns over pitch quality. The move comes after Gotham's 1-0 quarterfinal win over the Seattle Reign on Sunday, where players and coaches criticized the playing surface at Sports Illustrated Stadium.
Head coach Juan Carlos Amoros apologized for the pitch condition, calling it below the standard expected for a league quarterfinal. Players including Reign captain Jess Fishlock described the field as "atrocious," while Gotham midfielder Jaelin Howell called it "sandy" and "unstable." The NWSL had fined Gotham $10,000 for the field's state, though the club does not manage the venue as a secondary tenant to MLS side Red Bull New York (RBNY).
Despite a field consultant deeming the pitch FIFA-compliant on Friday, and representatives from the NWSL, Professional Referee Organization, and NWSL Players Association clearing it for play on Sunday, the visible sand and rugby lines from a previous event raised safety concerns. Gotham and the NWSL explored re-sodding or a hybrid grass-artificial solution, but RBNY's scheduled friendly against Club America on Saturday prevented timely completion.
RBNY stated they invest in the pitch year-round and it was cleared for all matches this season, but could not guarantee the additional work would be finished in time. Gotham captain Tierna Davidson acknowledged the difficulty of moving to a 5,000-seat venue, which will exclude many fans. The club has played at Icahn Stadium twice before, most recently in August 2025, when Amoros praised its pitch quality.
The last-minute venue change highlights broader logistical challenges in the NWSL, where roughly half the teams are secondary tenants in stadiums controlled by MLS clubs. Scheduling conflicts with MLS matches have forced multiple venue switches this postseason, including the Washington Spirit's semifinal relocation. Gotham will move to Etihad Park in 2028 but will remain a secondary tenant under New York City FC management, suggesting similar issues may persist.



