Manchester United have made their worst start to a Premier League season since 1986-87, with just one victory in their first 10 matches leaving them 18th in the table, one point above bottom club Crystal Palace. Club directors will meet in Monaco on Wednesday to discuss the future of head coach Michael Carrick, whose 10-month spell is under major scrutiny. If Carrick departs, it would mark an eighth permanent manager since Sir Alex Ferguson retired in 2013 – as many changes as the club made in the previous 68 years dating back to Sir Matt Busby's appointment in 1945.

BBC Sport outlines the leading candidates to replace the 45-year-old former player. Mauricio Pochettino, 54, has a long-standing link with United and a Premier League record of 150 wins in 294 games (1.77 points per game) with Tottenham. He recently signed a new contract with the USA national team through 2030, but his deal reportedly includes a $10 million buyout clause and provisions allowing him to leave for high-profile club jobs. Julian Nagelsmann, 39, resigned as Germany coach after a World Cup last-32 exit; he won the Bundesliga with Bayern Munich and has a strong Champions League win percentage (83.3%). United's director of recruitment Christopher Vivell knows him well from their time at RB Leipzig.

Eddie Howe, 48, left Newcastle in the summer after a 12th-placed finish but delivered the club's first major domestic trophy since 1955 with the League Cup and two top-five finishes. His Premier League record stands at 140 wins in 369 games (1.36 PPG), and Newcastle would command only modest compensation. Antonio Conte, 57, is a serial winner with five Serie A titles, a Premier League crown with Chelsea (30 wins in 38 games in 2016-17), and an FA Cup. However, his fiery nature and history of falling out with clubs – most recently at Tottenham in 2023 – could count against him. Unai Emery, 55, has revitalised Aston Villa since October 2022, leading them back to the Champions League and winning the Europa League. His Premier League record is 101 wins in 200 games (1.75 PPG), but he is expected to sign a new contract at Villa Park, making a move unlikely.

Carrick himself retains a Premier League record of 14 wins in 29 games (1.76 PPG) since his interim appointment in January 2026, during which he amassed the most wins (12) and points (39) of any manager for the remainder of the 2025-26 season. However, this term United have managed only three wins in 15 matches across all competitions, leaving them in the relegation zone and 18th after 10 games – their lowest position at this stage for 40 years. The Monaco summit on Wednesday will determine whether the club persists with Carrick or appoints a new permanent boss.