Past the midway point of the 2026 NFL season, several offseason decisions look increasingly costly for their teams. Here are five moves that could haunt franchises for years.
Indianapolis Colts: Signing Daniel Jones to an $88 Million Contract
After a promising eight-game stretch, the Colts re-signed quarterback Daniel Jones to an $88 million deal despite a career 70-47 touchdown-to-interception ratio, 84.3 passer rating, and 24-44-1 record from 2019-2024. General manager Chris Ballard also traded two first-round picks for cornerback Sauce Gardner, betting on Jones as a franchise passer. Jones went 1-4 with a 6-5 TD-INT line and 84.2 passer rating in his final five games before an Achilles tear. The Colts have since fired Ballard.
Tampa Bay Buccaneers: Extending Baker Mayfield for $165 Million
After Mayfield played through a shoulder injury and posted a 3-8 record with an 80.6 passer rating in his final 11 starts of 2025, the Buccaneers signed him to a three-year, $165 million extension with $110 million in new guarantees on September 8. Since then, Tampa Bay is 1-4 in games Mayfield has completed a pass, and he ranks among the league's worst in completion rate (60.6%), touchdown rate (2.1%), yards per attempt (6.5), and passer rating (74.9). His cap hit nearly doubles to $65.7 million in 2027.
Los Angeles Chargers: Hiring Mike McDaniel as Offensive Coordinator
The Chargers' offense ranks last in EPA per play (-0.219) entering Week 10, with fewer than 20 red-zone trips and a scoring rate under 30%. A two-time Pro Bowl quarterback has seen his interception rate more than double from 1.7% to 4.7% and his passer rating drop from 96.3 to 70.4. The unit went 37 consecutive drives without an offensive touchdown before snapping the streak.
Arizona Cardinals: Drafting Jeremiyah Love Third Overall
Love, considered the top prospect in the 2026 draft, has suffered three separate ankle injuries and is on injured reserve. In six games, he topped 65 rushing yards once and averaged under 3.5 yards per carry in three games. He has two or fewer receptions in four of six games and never reached 20 receiving yards. Meanwhile, later-round rookies such as Kaelon Black (90th overall) and Mike Washington Jr. (122nd) lead all rookies in rushing yards.
Minnesota Vikings: Quarterback Room Decisions
The Vikings traded former first-round pick J.J. McCarthy to the New York Giants for a fifth-round pick after head coach Kevin O'Connell appeared unwilling to start him. Minnesota then signed Kyler Murray for the veteran minimum and paired him with Carson Wentz, wasting a once-in-a-decade defense. O'Connell, known as a "quarterback whisperer," has faced criticism, with some suggesting defensive coordinator Flores might be better suited for the head coaching role.



