Questions about New York Yankees roster construction have emerged regarding captain Aaron Judge's potential role as a designated hitter while Giancarlo Stanton remains on the roster. An MLB insider weighed in on general manager Brian Cashman's plans for the 2026 season, suggesting it would be unusual roster construction if Judge were primarily used as a DH with Stanton also occupying that role.
The Yankees have both Judge and Stanton under contract through 2026, with both players having extensive injury histories that have limited their defensive availability in recent seasons. Judge, the 2022 American League MVP, has played significant time in right field when healthy, while Stanton has increasingly served as the primary DH.
Cashman's offseason strategy will likely address how to maximize both players' offensive production while managing their defensive workloads and injury risks. The Yankees finished the 2026 season without a playoff appearance, increasing pressure on the front office to optimize the roster around their two highest-paid position players.



