The 2026 NFL trade deadline passed without the blockbuster moves seen a year earlier, but several plausible deals could have strengthened playoff contenders. Here are three trades that agents and analysts believe teams may regret not completing.
Jonathan Taylor to New York Giants
The Indianapolis Colts, in fire‑sale mode after firing general manager Chris Ballard, reportedly sought a first‑round pick for running back Jonathan Taylor. The Giants were willing to offer a 2027 second‑round pick, a 2028 third‑round pick, and a 2028 sixth‑round pick for Taylor, who carries a $3.97 million remaining 2026 salary and a $4.60 million cap hit for Indianapolis. New York had $6.18 million in cap space and a clear need for a workhorse back. Taylor, 27, has two years and $34 million left on his contract after 2026. The Colts’ asking price, compared to the Christian McCaffrey trade in 2022, was seen as unrealistic given Taylor’s age and career carries (1,712 vs. McCaffrey’s 866 at the time of his trade).
Brian Thomas Jr. to Los Angeles Rams
Jacksonville Jaguars wide receiver Brian Thomas Jr., the 2024 first‑round pick, has seen his role vanish under new head coach Liam Coen — he went without a target in Week 9 for the first time in his career. The Jaguars, now 6‑2 and in win‑now mode, rebuffed interest despite Thomas’s $537,500 remaining 2026 salary. The Rams, decimated by injuries to Davante Adams (hamstring) and Puka Nacua (knee), could have used Thomas as a short‑term upgrade and a younger, cheaper alternative to the 32‑year‑old Adams. A 2027 second‑round pick — similar to the compensation Arizona received for Marvin Harrison Jr. — would have been a reasonable price, though Los Angeles lacked early‑round draft capital after acquiring Myles Garrett and trading for Trent McDuffie.
Tony Pollard to Green Bay Packers
Green Bay’s offense ranks last in rushing (68.2 yards per game) and lost Josh Jacobs to a broken finger. Tennessee Titans running back Tony Pollard, coming off back‑to‑back 100‑yard games and averaging 3.53 yards after contact per carry, was available for a conditional 2027 fourth‑round pick (becoming a third if Green Bay reaches Super Bowl LXI and Pollard leads the team in rushing). Pollard’s $3.61 million remaining 2026 salary fit within the Packers’ $5.67 million cap room. The 1‑7 Titans, already trading away Jeffery Simmons and Amani Hooker for draft capital, could have added another pick while moving an expiring contract; Pollard, 29, is unlikely to be re‑signed and would net at best a 2028 third‑round compensatory pick if he leaves in free agency.
All three deals were financially feasible and addressed clear roster needs, yet each team held firm on valuation or strategic direction. As the league year resumes in March, the missed opportunities may loom large in postseason evaluations.



