The job of a college football head coach has never been less focused on coaching football, making assistant and coordinator hires more critical than ever. Recent high-profile firings — such as Michigan's Jason Beck, who is owed more than $10 million after less than a year, Oregon's Drew Mehringer, and Oklahoma's Ben Arbuckle — show that patience for underperforming coordinators is evaporating. With the pressures facing coaching staffs in 2026, bad hires cost programs more than ever. Here are 10 of the worst coordinator hires of the past five years, including several that tanked College Football Playoff contenders this season.
Dino Babers, OC | Arizona | 2024
Babers arrived after 10 years as a head coach at Syracuse but his offense collapsed. Arizona went 4-8 in his lone season, sandwiched between a 10-win and a nine-win season. Quarterback Noah Fifita's completion rate dropped from 72% to 60%, yards per attempt fell from 8.6 to 6.9, and he doubled his highest interception mark.
Todd Grantham, DC | Oklahoma State | 2025
Grantham was fired after only four games despite a fully guaranteed three-year contract. In two games against Power Four opponents, his defense gave up a combined 114 points, including a 69-3 loss to Oregon — one of the worst performances in Oklahoma State history.
Alex Grinch, DC | USC | 2022
After a solid stint at Oklahoma, Grinch led some of the most stunningly terrible defenses at USC. The Trojans ranked No. 119 in total defense (432.8 yards per game) and allowed 6.3 yards per play against Power Four competition before Lincoln Riley fired him.
Freddie Kitchens, OC | North Carolina | 2025
The former NFL head coach led a wildly unorganized unit. The Tar Heels started the season with a combined 23 points against UCF and TCU, went 2-1 in games scoring at least 20 points, and managed only 20 points against three Power Four opponents.
Seth Littrell, OC | Oklahoma | 2024
Despite a strong track record at North Carolina and North Texas, Littrell's seven-game tenure produced Oklahoma's worst offense through seven games since 1961. A 34-3 Red River loss to Texas with a backup quarterback was the final straw.
Drew Mehringer, OC | Oregon | 2026
Elevated to replace Will Stein, Mehringer tanked one of the nation's most talented offenses. The Ducks fell from No. 5 to No. 49 in FEI offense, turning 426 yards into just 10 points in a 21-10 loss to Illinois. After his firing, Oregon scored 75 points over two games against ranked opponents, including a 41-28 win over No. 12 Ohio State.
Chad Morris, OC | Clemson | 2026
Morris, who hadn't called plays at the college level since 2020 at Auburn, led one of the most disorganized offenses in America. Clemson ranks No. 115 in total offense and No. 127 in yards per play, a full-yard-per-play regression from the previous year.
Mike Shula, OC | South Carolina | 2025
The former Alabama head coach and NFL coordinator was brought in to develop quarterback LaNorris Sellers but instead tanked his stock. Sellers' completion rate fell from 66% to 61%, and South Carolina went 4-8 under Shula, sandwiched between two eight-win seasons.
Tony White, DC | Florida State | 2025
White arrived as a major up-and-comer after leading Nebraska to a top-20 defense in 2024 on a $1.6 million average annual contract. Florida State fell to No. 122 in total defense in his second season, giving up 113 points in the final three games of Mike Norvell's tenure before interim coach Rick Stockstill fired him.
Holman Wiggins, OC | Texas A&M | 2026
A respected wide receiver coach, Wiggins proved unready as a playcaller. The Aggies dropped from No. 21 to No. 119 in yards per play despite returning key contributors. Quarterback Marcel Reed regressed from a productive dual-threat to eight touchdowns and eight interceptions, likely costing Texas A&M a bowl berth.



