SB Nation columnist Adam Gretz examines the debate surrounding Pittsburgh Penguins defenseman Declan Carlile, referencing a piece by Dan Muse that defends the 24-year-old blueliner while acknowledging criticism of his on-ice performance.
The discussion comes after Carlile appeared in the Penguins' October 22, 2026 game against the Florida Panthers at PPG Paints Arena, where he was photographed skating with the puck during the third period.
Muse's argument highlights contextual factors affecting Carlile's play, while Gretz notes that critics are justified in pointing out the defenseman's struggles through the early part of the 2026-27 NHL season.
