AthleticoView

Chairman of the Board: Ahmed Hammam

Editor-in-Chief: Ayman Badra

UEFA Champions League

Manchester United vs Roma: Referee Criticized for Soft Penalty and Missed Maguire Red Card

Manchester United vs Roma: Referee Criticized for Soft Penalty and Missed Maguire Red Card
UEFA Champions League · 21:11:34 - Thursday, 5 November 2026

Manchester United's Europa League clash with Roma has sparked controversy after the match official drew heavy criticism for awarding a soft penalty and failing to send off Harry Maguire for a potential red-card offense.

According to Football Italia, the referee's decisions during the November 4 encounter have been slammed by observers, with particular focus on a penalty award deemed generous and a challenge by United captain Maguire that many believed warranted dismissal.

The incident involving Maguire occurred at a crucial juncture in the match, with the England international escaping what appeared to be a clear sending-off offense. Meanwhile, the penalty decision swung momentum in a game where fine margins proved decisive.

Both decisions have fueled debate over officiating standards in European competition, with pundits and fans alike questioning the consistency of refereeing at this level.

Share this article: